Skip to main content

Reporting on the Police

 Almost a year after George Floyd's death sparked worldwide protests, the man who kneeled on his neck was ultimately convicted of murder and is facing decades in prison. This traumatic cultural moment has raised an important question for young journalists - how do you report on police activity?

The question has been raised in light of the initial press release from Minneapolis Police shortly after George Floyd's death. In a statement, the police said Floyd "appeared to be suffering medical distress" and was subsequently transported via ambulance to a hospital where he died "a short time later". At no point in the release was it made clear that Derek Chauvin had placed his knee on Floyd's neck for nearly 10 minutes while he gasped for air and told the officers that he could not breathe. This vague, misleading and wholly incorrect initial statement questions the whole premise of reporting solely on what police "said". 



If not for the video, that release may have been the final word on George Floyd. But of course, a bystanders video did show the actual events of that day, and a year later Chauvin was convicted of murder. Going forward, it is important for journalists to remember that police officers presenting the "official narrative" should never be the standalone source for a story, especially if the story involves potential police misconduct. 

An example where this is not done very well is this New York Times story about the police killing of Andrew Brown Jr. Here, the official narrative is heavily relied upon for the majority of the story, and it appears as though the Times did not make an effort to get any bystander accounts. 

Andrew Brown Jr. Shooting: Sheriff’s Deputy Kills Black Man in North Carolina - The New York Times (nytimes.com)

But based on this ABC News story, it appears there were indeed eyewitness accounts to dive into as they are cited in this story.

Bodycam video of Andrew Brown shooting will be redacted before shown to family (msn.com)

The nation's leading paper should take the lessons of George Floyd more seriously and improve its police reporting to reflect that the "official" narrative is only one particular narrative that may not be the truth.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Biden's First Press Conference

After over two months of waiting, the media finally got its chance to have a formal press conference with President Biden. The lack of a press conference turned into a mini-scandal of sorts, especially on right wing media outlets, but also mainstream media as well. As a result, you might expect that the DC press corps would come armed with a wide range of questions that produce valuable, insightful answers from the new President about the many problems facing the country. But the press conference was a boring, barely newsworthy affair that's most reported on answer involved the horserace politics of an election four years away.  The new President simply was somehow not asked about the pandemic that has dominated the news cycle for the last year. Instead, the majority of the questions centered on the surge of people arriving at the border from Central America. Immigration and border stories are important, and the problem isn't that he should not have been asked about that. But s...
7 comments
Read more

The Fake News Insurrection

 On January 6th, a mob invaded the United States Capitol and spilled blood in the name of a massive lie. Over the last several years, we have seen the meteoric rise of misinformation in the political ecosystem. While it has been with us for some time, it has taken a little longer for us to fully realize how real world events can be shaped by misinformation. For years, scholars watched how misinformation had the capacity to alter the real world. In Russia, misinformation became an essential tool for carrying out the desires of Vladimir Putin. In 2014, Russia annexed Crimea from Ukraine, and then flatly denied that they had done what they did. Misinformation in the Donbas region helped to stir up an all out war, and the toll of fake news was in full force.  In the United States, we have watched as fake news has grown in our country and studied the effects it may be having on the real world. But we have clearly failed to anticipate how quickly a fake news conspiracy can materiali...
5 comments
Read more

Internet Blackouts Signal Its Power

The internet is a political force. For the last few decades, researchers have been attempting to figure just what kind of force it really is. Is it a democratic force? An authoritarian force? Neither? Both? There are good arguments to be made either way. But researchers have found that, ultimately, the internet is a tool. It can be wielded for many different purposes depending on who is doing the wielding, and it is probably a little naïve to think of the internet as containing inherent political motives. As Clay Shirky put it in Foreign Affairs, "the use of social media tools - text message, e-mail, photo sharing, social networking, and the like - does not have a single preordained outcome." We have seen the internet turn governments upside down through the power of organized protest, and we have seen propaganda and censorship plague the online world to the liking of autocrats. It varies greatly from country to country, but in each case, we can see some clues as to which sid...
5 comments
Read more